I think it’s an awful shame that as a culture we enjoy turkey only on Turkey-Day. Turkey is more flavorful than chicken (if you do it right), better for you than red meat, and you can use nearly every piece of it as leftovers (or wishbones). Sadly, it’s also the focus of some major anxiety for lots of people.
Which is why, even though we celebrated Thanksgiving across town at the house of friends, Anton and I made our very own 19.5-pound bird the next day. This not only took the pressure off of us, since we didn’t have to present the bird in a gasp-worthy moment at the table, but it also netted us two gigantic tupperware containers of meat and almost 80 cups (that’s 20 quarts) of stock. Most of that has gone straight to the freezer, but a goodly portion has gone to making soup, some incredible sandwiches, and excellent dinners that made use of pre-cooked poultry. Because while I do love Thanksgiving dinner, it’s the week of leftovers that I really look forward to!
First off, the bird:
We went shopping the day after Thanksgiving to buy a roasting pan and rack, a gravy separator, a stockpot, and a probe thermometer (ours broke last week!). We got a few odd looks for buying turkey-roasting equipment the day after the turkey was meant to be roasted, but we got everything we needed and all was well.
The recipe we use is Cook’s Illustrated Turkey for a Crowd. It only takes about 3 hours, but requires you to flip the bird (hee hee) an hour into the roasting process to keep the breast juicy. Last year this was an ordeal that required three people (thanks Jenny!) and dirtied every spatula in the kitchen and more than one towel. This year, Anton discovered his turkey turners in a box and we managed the flip with ease! We slightly undercooked it on purpose, so that the breast was perfect (perfect, I tell you!) but the thighs were still slightly raw. After we took the rest of the meat off the bone, we nuked it in the microwave a little bit to finish it off.
For what we did with our embarrassment of turkey riches, check after the break: